Sat 7 DC United v New York City FC Major League Soccer · 21:00 UTC · Audi Field Possible · 55% in 2 days

New York City FC 1–1 CF Montreal Not in squad 31 Oct New York City FC 2–1 Atlanta United FC Started · off 28′ 28 Oct Orlando City SC 2–2 New York City FC Started · off 82′ 24 Oct New York City FC 1–1 Los Angeles FC Started 17 Oct Inter Miami 2–0 New York City FC Started · off 57′ 14 Oct Chicago Fire 2–1 New York City FC Started · off 60′ 10 Oct Atlanta United FC 2–2 New York City FC Unused sub 26 Sep New York City FC 0–1 New York Red Bulls Came on · 28′ 18 Sep